Baron, 2000, no comprehensive decision models have emerged from this effort, nor have any models been shown empirically to apply to the creation of new firms in the face of knightian uncertainty. Such behavior does not make the individual irrational, since the intransitive choices are not assumed to be in pursuit of some goal. Basic concepts of statistical decision theory lecturer. Although, both cases are described here, the majority of this report focuses. The decisionmaking theory in the analysis is that of expected utility under a nonadditive probability measure, that is, the choquet expected utility model of preference. The concept acknowledges some fundamental degree of ignorance, a limit to knowledge, and an essential unpredictability of future events. Stimulated by frank knights book, risk, uncertainty and profit, i present a theory of innovation based on what i term knightian decision theory. The role of complementary assets across the different stages of a firms value chain in facilitating value creation and value appropriation from technological innovation remains a key area of interest in strategy and entrepreneurship research. There has been increased interest in the implications of knightian uncertainty for managerial decisionmaking and recent research has pointed to the very different implications for managers decisionmaking according to whether organizations are conceived to operate in a context of knightian uncertainty, versus a.
Theory of decision making under uncertainty based on papers by itzhak gilboa, massimo marinacci, andy postlewaite, and david schmeidler. An infogap perspective decision making in times of. However, current thinking on complementary assets operates with an unstated boundary conditionthat relevant assets and asset configurations are. One solution offered by caballero to stem these moments of panic is governmentissued investment insurance for large financial institutions.
Weakening the independence axiom, journal of economic theory 40, 309318. The theory would not be contradicted if a decision maker cannot be persuaded to move from one undominated decision to another, as i shall explain presently. Decision theory tries to throw light, in various ways, on the former type of period. Fundamentals of decision theory university of washington. Decision theory be interpreted as the longrun relative frequencies, and theexpected payo. The purpose of this paper is to explore a source of nominal price rigidity and nonneutrality of money in a model of monopolistic competition under knightian uncertainty. It is here that we see the contribution of this study.
The inertia assumption is that there is such a thing as the status quo and an alternative is accepted only if it is preferred to the status quo. It is standardly distinguished from a parallel enterprise, normative decision theory, which seeks to provide an account of the choices that people ought to be disposed to make. Knightian decision theory and econometric inference core. Descriptive decision theory is concerned with characterising and explaining regularities in the choices that people are disposed to make. The decision making theory in the analysis is that of expected utility under a nonadditive probability measure, that is, the choquet expected utility model of preference. Decision theory is a set of concepts, principles, tools and techniques that help the decision maker in dealing with complex decision problems under uncertainty. Knightian uncertainty and moral hazard request pdf. Uncertainty in mechanism design university of pittsburgh. Introduction to decision theory ecn 203c, fall 2008. The indeterminateness of decision may be viewed as a defect of the knightian theory, since theories should explain as much as possible. Incomplete preferences and uncertainty in this section we brie. Quasiexpected utility theory with loss aversion and endogeneous status quo point dekel, e 1986, an axiomatic characterization of preferences under uncertainty.
Decision theory is concerned with the reasoning underlying an agents choices, whether this is a mundane choice between taking the bus or getting a taxi, or a more farreaching choice about whether to pursue a demanding political career. Review of knightian decision theory the basic ideas and notation of the knightian decision theory of bewley 4,5 are briefly as llows. In economics, knightian uncertainty is a lack of any quantifiable knowledge about some possible occurrence, as opposed to the presence of quantifiable risk e. In the presence of knightian uncertainty, matters become more complex, as now a decision maker carries a set of probability measures and consequently every action is associated with an interval of expected costs walley, 1991. An introduction to decision theory this uptodate introduction to decision theory offers comprehensive and accessible discussions of decision making under ignorance and risk, the foundations of utility theory, the debate over subjective and objective probability, bayesianism, causal decision theory, game theory and social choice theory.
Risk management and decision theory 6 impact of a risk event that a firm could withstand and remain a going concern. Thinking, fast and slow by daniel kahneman, the black swan. The objective of this paper is to identify the best environment for veteran nonprofits to thrive through analyzing the economics of charitable giving, game theory, and knightian uncertainty. Most presentations of decision theory work from luce and raiffas 1957 building on knight, 1921. Section 4 compares infogap and minmax decision methodologies. In chapter one, i derive the optimal capital structure of a firm when its manager is ambiguityaverse. A theory of choice under uncertainty is proposed which removes the completeness assumption from the anscombeaumann formulation of savages theory and introduces an inertia assumption. I am proud to come to the zenith of my venture into the world of risk management and decision theory with this dissertation. I uncertainty or knightian uncertainty i objectivity. Decision theory as the name would imply is concerned with the process of making decisions. Ellsberg paradox efore we discuss the ellsberg paradox, it is helpful to mention the expected utility theory, of which the paradox is a violation and risk aversion, which is a part of the expected utility theory, and an. The theory includes a concept of uncertainty aversion, a behavioral property manifested by reluctance to undertake new unevaluatable risks.
Ellsbergs experiments showed that knightian s distinction. The concept acknowledges some fundamental degree of ignorance, a limit to knowledge, and an essential unpredictability. A formal philosophical introduction richard bradley london school of economics and political science march 9, 2014 abstract decision theory is the study of how choices are and should be. If preferences are not complete, some alternatives are incomparable. Jun 02, 2010 one solution offered by caballero to stem these moments of panic is governmentissued investment insurance for large financial institutions. I argue that some standard uses of classical inference are knightian in spirit, even though the formal justification of classical methods uses the frequentist notion of probability. Infogap theory is used to model the distributional uncertainty in the pdf of the threshold for actuation of the explosive material. Theory of decision making under uncertainty based on papers by itzhak gilboa, massimo marinacci, andy postlewaite, and david schmeidler idc herzliya. Risk management and decision theory 2 acknowledgements it has been a rather educative blast, so to speak.
It discusses how policies change as we account for knightian uncertainty. This paper concentrates entirely on knightian uncertainty and does not consider the statistical problem of estimating a pdf. This theory is one way of giving rigorous expression. My dissertation aims to understand a firms optimal capital structure decision when it confronts knightian uncertainty. Ellsbergs experiments showed that knightians distinction is empirically meaningful. I a mode of behavior is irrational for a given decision maker, if, when the decision maker behaves in this mode, and is then exposed to the analysis of her behavior, she regrets it feels embarrassed.
Decision theory stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. A model of keynesian under knightian uncertainty core. In this paper i attempt to reconcile the apparent definiteness of econometric practice with the vagueness of subjective probabilities assumed in knightian decision theory. Decision theory under ambiguity etner 2012 journal. A decision problem under uncertainty is defined by the following elements. Decisiontheory tries to throw light, in various ways, on the former type of period. Decision making under ambiguity representation of incomplete beliefs and preferences bewley, t. In that theory, greater uncer inty aversion makes decision makers more eager to equalize utility levels in different states. The bonus system models the bonus acquired for achieving a goal within an organisation.
Bewley, knightian decision theory part i, decisions in econ. This theory is one way of giving rigorous expression to frank. Note that agent here stands for an entity, usually an individual person, that is capable of. Incomplete preferences under completeness, any pair of alternatives can be ranked.
The impact of the highly improbable by nassim nicholas tale. Managerial decision making under knightian uncertainty. Decision theory, decision theory lecture notes, decision. The extension to statistical decision theory includes decision making in the presence of statistical knowledge which provides some information where there is uncertainty.
Decision theory concepts and methods 5 dependent on. More specifically, decision theory deals with methods for determining the optimal course of action when a number of alternatives are available and their consequences cannot be. I argue that some standard uses of classical inference are knightian. Knightian decision theory and econometric inference.
My model predicts substantially lower leverage for such firms, in comparison to traditional static tradeoff models. Although it is now clearly an academic subject of its own right, decision theory is. Ellsberg paradox efore we discuss the ellsberg paradox, it is helpful to mention the expected utility theory, of which the paradox is a violation and risk aversion, which is. If one accepts this argument, then it is of interest to know what level of uncertainty aversion corresponds to the popular 5% significance level.
Descriptive decision theory stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. Contemporary issues in business, management and education vilnius gediminas technical university, lithuania proccedings of international conference contemporary issues in business, management and education 2015 vgtu technika, 2015. The elements of decision theory are quite logical and even perhaps intuitive. Such unexplained preferences or choices may be erratic and intransitive, but this is no cause for concern. The starting point is a relation of strict preference, defined over a topological vector ace, x, of lotteries. Bayesian decision theory the basic idea to minimize errors, choose the least risky class, i.
A similar criterion of optimality, however, can be applied to a wider class of decision problems. I will teach the second half and will focus on choice. The focus is on analysis and management of both statistical variability of measurements and nonprobabilistic uncertainty in probability distributions distributional uncertainty. The usual prescription for decision making under risk is to select an action that maximizes expected utility. Section 3 uses a simple example of bank loan decisions to illustrate methodological implications of infogap theory for decisions under knightian uncertainty. Knightian uncertainty and moral hazard giuseppe lopomoa, luca rigottib,1, chris shannonc afuqua school of business, duke university bdepartment of economics, university of pittsburgh cdepartment of economics, university of california berkeley abstract this paper presents a principalagent model in which the agent has imprecise beliefs. An analogue of dynamic programming called maxmin programming is developed. Knightian decision theory and econometric inference, cowles foundation discussion papers 868, cowles foundation for research in economics, yale university.
1131 1048 595 1496 720 17 769 465 830 1123 1242 821 1279 238 979 1127 856 1356 205 1371 948 259 73 819 798 763 518 192 834 1306 525 1269 1337 443 526 435